From "Essential Guide to Effect Sizes" by Paul D. Ellis (2010)
Most psychology students will be introduced to the concept of Type 1 and Type 2 errors in a statistics class.
The aim of this post is to explore a couple of quick ways in which psychology instructors can make sure their students don't confuse Type 1 and Type 2 errors, and in doing so extend their understanding of null hypothesis significance testing.
One very simple way of understanding the difference between Type 1 and Type 2 errors is to think about erroneous test results. As clearly illustrated in the pregnancy example above.
Another great way is to provide a 'real world' perspective. Larry Gonick does an excellent job of doing this in his book - The Cartoon Guide to Statistics -, in which he suggests that we think of hypothesis testing/significance tests in terms of a smoke detector in our home. Gonick notes that household smoke-detectors tend to go off every time "you make the toast too dark" and this is a Type 1 error (an alarm without a fire) as opposed to a Type 2 error (a fire without an alarm). Adding that:
Every cook knows how to avoid a Type 1 error: Just remove the batteries. Unfortunately, this increases the incidence of Type 2 errors!
Outline Gonick's smoke alarm example and then get your students to come up with their own real world illustration of the difference between Type 1 and Type 2 errors. This task works best when students are divided into small groups. Not only does this allow students to bounce ideas off each other but it also means you can get each group to present their example to the rest of the class. You might also want to get the class as a whole to decide which is the best example and why.
How does the issue of Type 1 and Type 2 errors relate to the much publicized replication crisis in psychology?
Identify a research practice that is likely to increase the likelihood of a Type 1 error, and one research practice that can help prevent false-positive findings.
If you would like to learn more (Go on! You know you want to!) there is a section on the website dedicated to psychology research methods that includes an experimental psychology tutorial for psychology students which is free, easy to follow and not scary at all.
David Webb is the owner, writer and host of four websites built around his teaching and research interests; including All-About-Psychology.Com which receives over two million visits a year.
A passionate promoter of psychology through social media, over 890,000 people follow his psychology Facebook page and he is featured on the British Psychological Society list of the 100 most followed psychologists and neuroscientists on Twitter.
Feb 25, 21 04:05 AM
Psychology Expert Q & A: Fascinating interviews with experts spanning a range of psychology topic areas.
Feb 25, 21 02:16 AM
Excellent Q & A with Clinical-Forensic Psychologist and author, Barry Bricklin, Ph.D.
Feb 22, 21 11:21 PM
Superstition in The Pigeon by psychology legend B. F. Skinner demonstrates how accidental connections between a ritual and favorable consequences can establish and maintain superstitious behavior.